President Joe Biden’s executive order spurring an “all of government” approach to registering voters could raise questions about whether the effort squares with a law prohibiting political activity on federal property.
Congress will look into such questions, Rep. Claudia Tenney, R-N.Y., co-chair of the House Election Integrity Caucus, told The Daily Signal.
“We’re looking at potential Hatch Act violations,” Tenney said last week in an interview. “We have these former political operatives now, and actually even government agencies, engaging in political operations to get votes out, which are roles reserved to the states and not to these federal operatives.”
The Hatch Act prohibits federal employees from engaging in partisan political activity while on duty and while in government offices, wearing government uniforms, in government vehicles, or using taxpayer dollars.
Congress passed the law in 1939 after a scandal in which executive branch officials in President Franklin Roosevelt’s administration threatened to withhold benefits and loans to those who didn’t vote Democrat, and promised jobs to those who did vote Democrat. The law is named for its sponsor, the late Sen. Carl Hatch, D-N.M.
A government watchdog group contends that Biden’s executive order on voter registration could cause federal employees to violate three federal laws.
Since Biden issued the order in March 2021, several agencies have responded by outlining actions they will be involved in. These include:
- The Justice Department announced guidance for states to increase awareness of voting rights for convicted criminals, in compliance with Biden’s order. States differ on restoring voting rights to convicted felons after they serve their sentences.
- Based on a Freedom of Information Act request, The Daily Signal first reported last month that the Department of Housing and Urban Development is engaging in voter registration efforts that in some cases allow mass collection of registration forms by local public housing officials.
- The Department of Homeland Security said it will focus on voter registration “at the end of naturalization ceremonies for the hundreds of thousands of citizens naturalized each year.”
- The Education Department said it will focus on “increasing civic engagement at the elementary school, secondary school, and higher education level, helping more than 67 million students.”
Biden’s order states that agencies will “promote voter registration and voter participation” and will be “soliciting and facilitating approved, nonpartisan third-party organizations and state officials to provide voter registration services on agency premises.”
The order is similar to recommended executive actions on voting from Demos, a liberal nonprofit. Demos did not respond to a request for comment for this report.
Government agencies working with outside organizations that have a political bent is concerning, Tenney told The Daily Signal.
“It really concerns me that there’s a blurred line between these federal agencies and even funding agencies. And we’re even funding salaries within the federal government by the taxpayers to engage in political operations like Demos and others,” Tenney said in the May 24 interview.
“It’s really unacceptable. It should be struck down. And we should be suing over these [issues and] we know that there’s lawsuits either filed or pending on these issues,” the New York Republican said.
The Biden administration needs to be more transparent, said Stewart Whitson, legal director for the Foundation for Government Accountability, an ethics watchdog group. But based on what is known, Whitson said, the president’s executive order potentially violates the Hatch Act.
“Executive Order 14019 seems designed to target voters that are more likely to vote Democrat,” Whitson, a former FBI supervisory agent, told The Daily Signal. “Voter participation means voter mobilization. If the federal employees are engaged in getting people to the polls, that is political activity.”
Biden’s order has similarities to actions that originally prompted the Hatch Act, Whitson said.
“It was based on a 1939 scandal where the national Democratic Party was using the government to get more votes,” he said. “This is strikingly similar.”
Hans von Spakovsky, a former Justice Department lawyer who is a senior legal fellow at The Heritage Foundation, previously told The Daily Signal that the president’s order poses problems under the Hatch Act. (The Daily Signal is Heritage’s multimedia news organization.)
“If an individual is dealing with government—whether for Social Security, Medicaid, or veterans benefits—when a government clerk tells them to register to vote,” von Spakovsky said, “the typical reaction for someone getting government benefits is: ‘I better vote for the party in power, or my benefits will be denied.’”
Whitson said Biden’s order also could prompt violations of the Antideficiency Act, which prohibits federal employees from obligating tax dollars not authorized by Congress and prohibits any federal agency from accepting voluntary service from individuals.
The executive order refers to working with “third parties” and “nonprofit organizations” to assist in increasing voter registration and participation.
The president’s order also could lead federal employees to violate the National Voter Registration Act, a 1993 law better known as the Motor Voter Law, Whitson said. That law authorizes federal agencies to engage in specified activities to ease voter registration, but Biden’s order extends beyond the boundaries of the law, he said.
The White House did not respond to The Daily Signal’s inquiries for this report.
The Biden administration unsuccessfully pushed Democrat-sponsored voting initiatives in Congress that would have nationalized election administration, which traditionally has been a state responsibility.
Have an opinion about this article? To sound off, please email letters@DailySignal.com and we’ll consider publishing your edited remarks in our regular “We Hear You” feature. Remember to include the url or headline of the article plus your name and town and/or state.