Editor’s note: This is a lightly edited transcript of today’s video from Daily Signal senior contributor Victor Davis Hanson. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to see more of his videos.
Hello, this is Victor Davis Hanson for the Daily Signal.
We’re hearing a lot of criticism, both from the Left and the Right, the extreme right, about neocons, neocons, neocons.
And the criticism is that a group of people called neocons have hijacked the Trump MAGA foreign policy, usually doing the service of Israel, and they’re unduly influenced by a Jewish lobby, and they don’t represent the real interests of the United States.
Neoconservative, the word that they’re abbreviating, just means new conservative. Where did it come from? It came from the 1970s and ’80s, when a group of very distinguished liberals, Jewish and non-Jewish, decided that they’d had it with Jimmy Carter. He did not react in a muscular fashion to the Iranian hostage-taking of ’79 and ’80, and he wasn’t standing up to the Soviet Union.
They wanted to adopt the Reagan doctrine of we win, they lose. Who were they? Well, there were some Jewish Americans, Irving Kristol, Norman Podhoretz, but there were also non-Jewish people, James Q. Wilson, Bill Bennett, especially Jeane Kirkpatrick. And they all said that from now on, they were going to support the foreign policy of Republicans.
TRENDING ARTICLES
They disagreed with traditional Republicans on a number of issues—the border. I can remember that I wrote “Mexifornia”, a book calling for strict border security and deportations of illegal aliens, in 2003, and the neoconservative James Q. Wilson, in Commentary, attacked me. And he said that I was sort of paranoid and that my comparisons—that if we didn’t close our border, we’d end up like Europe—were completely ill-founded.
So they had different views. That group kind of gained steam in 1997, after the first Gulf War. Bill Kristol and Robert Kagan and Dick Cheney at that time, and Don Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, John Bolton, Francis Fukuyama—they formed something called the Project for the New American Century. They were going to be proactive, and they were going to, in some cases, topple regimes to nation-build, make countries more like us.
They didn’t do much from ’97 until 9/11. And then they came to the fore and said we have to get rid of the Taliban. Ninety percent of Americans agreed with them. And then we can’t just put a theocracy in place, so we’ll put Mr. [Hamid] Karzai in and hope he has a democracy. And we’ll do the same thing with Saddam Hussein, since he was entertaining terrorists.
He was slaughtering his own people. He had threatened George Bush. There were 21 writs that Congress approved. Congress approved going in there. Neither one of those worked out to our satisfaction, and for all practical purposes, neoconservatism was dead because it was responsible, people felt, for two costly wars.
So, as a reaction, Donald Trump came on the scene, and he said, I’m going to be a Jacksonian, not an isolationist, not a neoconservative nation-builder. I will react, or I will be preemptive if I think there is a threat, but I will not get involved on the ground. I will not have lengthy wars. Okay, you can argue over Iran, but we have not gotten on the ground, and we’ve only been kinetic for 38 days.
What he was talking about is getting rid of Qasem Soleimani, the Iranian terrorist general, and [Abu Bakr] al-Baghdadi, the ISIS head. In the first term, he destroyed the ISIS caliphate, killed numerous Russian Wagner Group mercenaries, and he got rid of [Nicolas] Maduro. And he bombed Iran in 2025 for about 20 hours. Okay. That was Jacksonianism.
Now the Iranian war has brought out people who say, “Well, there are all these neoconservatives running Trump’s foreign policy.” But I don’t know any people who are in the MAGA movement who are voicing neoconservative domestic policies. No one’s calling for choice, abortion on demand, like many neoconservatives did.
Nobody wants an open border. Nobody wants people to come in across the border illegally and then not to be deported. That’s not part of the movement of MAGA. So, in foreign policy, nobody’s saying we need to put a division in and take over Tehran. Nobody’s saying that we’ve got to remove the regime and then stay there and build a democracy.
It might be viable, might not, but nobody’s saying it. Nobody is even saying that I am a neoconservative and I’m proud of it. No one is. They call Marco Rubio a neoconservative. He’s not saying he’s a neoconservative. He might have said he agreed with neoconservatives 10 years ago or 15, during the Iraq War, but not now.
Who are the neoconservatives? Well, there are two groups, I think. There are people in National Review magazine, there are people in The Dispatch, an online magazine, there are people in The Wall Street Journal, and they feel that, as neoconservatives, they want free and unfettered trade.
They’re against the tariffs. They don’t really care about deporting illegal aliens. They feel that they will assimilate eventually. They feel we’re too restrictive on immigration, that there is always going to be some illegal immigration. They feel deportations are too excessive, or at least they’re bad optics.
And they feel that, from time to time, we might have to go into various countries and occupy them if necessary and build democracies. And the old neoconservatives, the people who were the most prominent, Francis Fukuyama, Bill Kristol, Robert Kagan—they’re all Democrats. They’re all liberals. So what really is the neoconservative label?
What is that label? It’s basically synonymous with your anger at Israel in general and Jewish people in particular. And so now we say you’re a neoconservative, and that is supposed to be a synonym for a puppet of the Israelis or too pro-Jewish.
I want to remind people that Israel receives about .05 of the federal budget and somewhere between 4% and 7% of annual foreign aid, and that’s going to end in 2027.
So the idea that the Israelis are puppet masters and Donald Trump is their puppet is absolutely absurd.
Let me just finish. There are no self-proclaimed neoconservatives. I don’t know anybody in the MAGA movement who says, “I’m a neoconservative.” I do know a lot of people accuse those who supported trying to get rid of the nuclear program in Iran of being neoconservative, but none of them have said, “I’m a neoconservative, and part of neoconservatism is to go into Iran.”
In fact, instead, the people who said you have to deal with that nuclear threat, as Donald Trump is attempting to do, say there are certain parameters. We’re not going to go in and try to change the regime. That would be good if we did, but that’s not our primary goal. It’s to get rid of their nuclear material.
We’re not going to land on the ground with airborne troops. We’re not going to insert the 1st Infantry Division. We’re not going to try to overthrow the regime. None of that. It’s very different. So neoconservatives means really nothing other than a coded and more polite form of saying, “The Jews did it. The Jews did it.”
We publish a variety of perspectives. Nothing written here is to be construed as representing the views of the Daily Signal.

Read the first chapter of The Woketopus right now for FREE
Today, even with President Trump’s victory, leftist elites have their tentacles in every aspect of our government.
The Daily Signal’s own Tyler O’Neil exposes this leftist cabal in his new book, The Woketopus: The Dark Money Cabal Manipulating the Federal Government.
In this book, O’Neil reveals how the Left’s NGO apparatus pursues its woke agenda, maneuvering like an octopus by circumventing Congress and entrenching its interests in the federal government.
You can read the first chapter of this new book for FREE in this eBook, The Woketopus: Chapter One using the secure link below.

The Daily Signal depends on the support of readers like you.






